When it comes to motor oils and other automotive fluids, you always want to go for the best and most reliable options, and there’s nothing wrong with that. And as consumers, we also tend to opt for well known and reputable brands- for good reason.
Even with the prevalence of new, up and coming brands that offer superior quality products, nothing beats the quality and reliability that established brands can offer. Some of these household brands include Castrol and Mobil 1.
At the end of the day, you’re almost always sure that products from these brands are guaranteed to ensure the health and performance of your car, which is what we all want. But, just how do these brands compare to each other?
When it comes to the question of Castrol edge vs Mobil 1, which is better? Let’s see.
Castrol oils at a glance
As a brand, Castor oils are popular for their wide variety of top quality products that are highly suitable for almost all vehicle types and vehicle conditions, and these products come at an affordable price range, which is why they are well loved by the general population.
For general purposes and most types of vehicle maintenance requirements, you can always rely on finding a Castrol product that will work for you.
About the company
Castrol is one of the leading brands when it comes to high performance engine oils for cars and other automotives. The company began as a start-up back in the 19th century in London, with its name derived from castor oil as one of the primary ingredients in their products.
The superior quality and marketability of these products eventually culminated in the company’s growth as a common household brand. It’s now a subsidiary as British Petroleum, and has a wide range of products, from consumer-grade engine oils that the average driver can work with, to industrial products that are used for space explorations.
The Castrol company markets various brands under the Castrol name, and their premium lineup is named Castrol Edge. It has the highest performing products in their entire collection, which are so great they are often used for supercars and race cars.
This is because Castrol Edge motor oils are made of fully synthetic formulations that are specifically engineered for performance and high mileage. They are also made with a unique Titanium technology that offers three times higher viscosity stability than other oils in the market.
As such, Castrol Edge products are a popular choice for most car manufacturers and professional racing teams. These oils are also suitable for various high-end automotive brands such as Jaguar, Volkswagen, Audi, and Land Rover. If you want a clean and high performing engine, Castrol Edge is the name you should remember.
Mobil 1 oils at a glance
Mobil 1 oils nowadays are generally marketed as higher-end products and are a highly suitable choice for new and well-maintained vehicles, which, if I’m being frank, makes up for a huge part of the driving population anyway.
And, these oils are also suitable for a wide variety of applications and come at a competitive price, so you definitely don’t have to worry about paying for overpriced products. That said, it’s still quite sad that Mobil 1 doesn’t seem to be interested in manufacturing products for older vehicles and those that need a lot of work to stay in good condition.
About the company
Mobil 1 has always been a big brand and a major player in the oil industry ever since its inception about a hundred years ago. In fact, it was even more of a powerhouse than it is today, but seeing as we all still know and love the brand, the downsizing isn’t really noticeable.
The company has experienced a few changes of ownership throughout the century, but that hasn’t affected the quality of their performance heavy products. And, Mobil 1 has always been actively involved in the research and development side of synthetic engine oils, so they don’t just market their product as the best, they make sure that it’s actually true.
While the company’s entire engine oil product line is excellent and well-performing, they really went all out with the Mobil 1 lineup, which is their premium engine oil brand that the company has continuously worked on developing and marketing, and successfully, too.
With this premium brand name of course comes products that offer superior performance, especially for new vehicle models and for high-performance engines. These are mostly fully synthetic engine oils that are guaranteed to maximize your engine’s capabilities and service life.
Interestingly enough, there are even Mobil 1 products for flying jets, so it’s really a wide range of top performing motor oils. It just may not be the best option for older automobiles.
Castrol Edge vs Mobil 1 Comparison Guide
As you know by now, both Castrol Edge and Mobil 1 are excellent and high performing products. But, where do they really stand when compared with each other? Which engine oil brand is the best, and in what department?
I say in which department, because we can’t just really generalize a blanket statement on which brand is better. There needs to be certain metrics to serve as our point of comparison, and we can decide from there.
I’m talking about the common marketing groups of motor oils, or the most common features that motor oils are advertised under. For example, some engine oils are marketed as best for heavy duty performance, some for prolonging the lifespan of your engine, and so on.
Let’s examine each of these niche markets one by one and see whether Castrol Edge or Mobil 1 is the better brand for each.
Most motor oils are marketed with excellent superior cleaning properties, which is an important feature for maintaining the engine and keeping it in good working condition. Now, what you have to understand is most, if not all, motor oils have some degree of cleaning capacity, since these are naturally equipped with detergents and dispersant additives.
The question is just how high the concentration of these additives is in the motor oil, which is of importance especially if you have a poorly maintained engine that can really benefit from some thorough cleaning.
Now, as I’ve mentioned earlier, Mobil generally doesn’t focus on coming up with products for older and poorly maintained engines, so when it comes to cleaning properties, Castrol Edge is a more suitable brand.
Another common and often bought type of motor oil is the one with engine preservation capabilities, meaning, an engine oil that can maintain the quality and condition of your vehicle, so it lasts for much longer even when pushed to its limits.
This is achieved by making use of various additives mixed in the oil, in order to offer various properties such as resistance to friction, corrosion, rust, and premature wearing. This type of oil doesn’t necessarily make your engine better, it just maintains the current condition of your engine, keeps it that way, and prevents it from getting worse.
Generally speaking, Mobil 1 is a better choice in terms of preservation qualities, although there is an exception- when it comes to conventional motor oils, the magnatec additives of Castrol Edge make it the more suitable option.
There are also special types of motor oil that are designed to provide the maximum performance possible that is required for certain high-performance vehicles, such as tuner cars, and of course, professional race cars.
In this department, there are even more subtypes of engine oils depending on what kind of car you have and how performance heavy its engine is. Nonetheless, there is a clear winner of which brand works better.
I’m talking about Mobil 1, which offers a full range of high performance products that are guaranteed to give you the best time on the road, whether it’s for high-speed driving, drifting, or whatnot. Castrol Edge oils are simply not designed for these types of applications.
High mileage oils
If what you want is an equal part serving of cleaning properties and preservation capabilities to ensure that your engine performs well and stays in good condition for the longest time possible, then what you’re looking for is a high mileage oil.
Various brands actually offer motor oils for this specific category, but not all of them perform equally. That’s because the efficiency of the product largely depends on the types and quality of the additives used to make the viscosity of the oil and its longevity effects work effectively.
When talking about motor oils that can give you a high mileage, your best choice is Mobil 1. The engine oils in their lineup are pretty much always marketed as high mileage, and they don’t fail to deliver. Although, Castrol Edge certainly competes, especially for older engines.
Oils for diesel engines
One thing that all decent car owners know is that different engine oils are manufactured for different types of engines and what kind of fuel they run on. There are oils designed to work with gasoline, and some with diesel, for example.
Although nowadays, motor oils are being engineered in such a way that they can work well with either gasoline or diesel engines, especially those with full synthetic formulations. But if you have a particularly old car model that has a diesel engine, you might still want to opt for a specially formulated engine oil for diesel.
In this aspect, it might also actually be better for you to try other brands rather than Castrol Edge or Mobil 1, since both of these have largely shifted to all purpose oils. But if you really want to choose between the two, Mobil 1 does have a performance diesel oil, as well as a diesel motor oil for commercial trucks.
Read also: Best diesel fuel additive thoroughly reviewed
When it comes to older engines, a majority of these still make use of conventional motor oils, and it’s unfortunately not possible to shift to other types of oil, as it can damage the already sensitive condition of even the most well-preserved engines of old cars.
As such, sticking with conventional motor oil is the only option. This is a type of motor oil that makes use of pure petroleum products, plus the occasional additives to increase performance. The good thing is, conventional oils are cheap, although you won’t get as much lubrication.
For this type of engine oil, Castrol is your best and only option out of the two brands, again since Mobil 1 doesn’t manufacture any products for older engines.
Full synthetic oils
Contrary to the soon becoming obsolete conventional oil, full synthetic oils are all the rage these days and are what’s being used on most new car models, for the simple reason that they just perform better in every conceivable aspect as compared to any other oil type.
And, full synthetic oils are also quickly becoming compatible with almost all engine and fuel types, so the only issue one might have with this type of oil is that it’s more expensive than the other options.
On the question of which brand is better, I’ll have to go with Mobil 1, since they have a full research and development wing dedicated to furthering the performance and quality of their full synthetic oils, and that’s clearly evident in their product lineup.
Somewhere in between conventional oils and full synthetic oils is a certain oil type called synthetic blend, which is a balanced mix of performance that you get from synthetic oils and suitability for older engines that comes from conventional oils.
Synthetic blends are a great and affordable option if you have an old car but you don’t want it to feel old when driving. And in terms of which brand you should trust, you can actually go in either direction here, although I’d lean towards Castrol Edge.
Read also: Best diesel engine oil
It’s clearly evident that both Castrol Edge and Mobil 1 are excellent motor oil brands regardless of what metric you’re using to measure their products’ performance. I’m sure you don’t even need convincing when I say that these two brands are reliable and trustworthy.
That said, no one brand offers the perfect solution to every problem, so if you’re choosing between Castrol Edge vs Mobil 1, it still really depends on what you want to get out of the product.
In general, Castrol Edge is an excellent choice if you want a smooth driving experience and a vehicle that lasts long despite its age and condition, while Mobil 1 will keep your engines in pristine condition and high performance.